Actress Jen Lilley, best known to daytime fans for her unforgettable runs on General Hospital and Days of Our Lives, recently sat down for a candid, wide-ranging interview on Richard Taite’s We’re Out of Time podcast. Lilly played Theresa Donovan on Days, and for a while, Maxie Jones on GH. During the conversation, she opened up about her new World War II drama Jimmy, honoring veterans, her 15-year battle with eating disorders, her Christian faith, her passion for foster care advocacy, and her Christmas is Not Cancelled toy drive.
Of course, soap fans, like ourselves, were especially eager to hear her dish on the behind-the-scenes chaos surrounding her 2023 Days of Our Lives return, and how she suddenly ended up getting replaced as Theresa Donovan by co-star Emily O’Brien (currently playing Gwen Rizschech).
Jen Lilley’s Days of Our Lives Return Started With a Simple Request
According to Lilley, the whole ordeal started with a sweet gesture following the passing of her beloved co-star John Aniston, who played Victor Kiriakis. Knowing the show sometimes brings familiar faces back for one-off memorial episodes, Lilley decided to reach out to the powers-that-be to pitch a quick visit to Salem.
After all, the show did reach out to her to return for one episode when they honored Peggy McCay (Caroline Brady). However, she could not do it because she was doing her very first Hallmark movie.
“I had made the mistake of emailing them and saying, ‘Hey, you know, whenever you do the episode for John Aniston, it would be really fun if Theresa just came back for’—I said a few episodes, shook up Salem, and left,” Lilley explained.
The show loved the idea and told her to circle back in February since they hadn’t filmed the tribute yet. Unfortunately, wires got crossed behind the scenes.
“So I circled back, and in the interim, they thought I was still there. And so they got really excited that I wanted to come back, and they fully wrote the character back without asking me,” she shared. “So then they were like, ‘Okay, here’s all the things we’ve planned,’ and I was like, ‘Oh no, I can’t come back full-time, guys.’ Like, I thought it was like a couple episodes. So they ended up having to recast me.”
“I Didn’t Know I Was Being Replaced”
At first, production tried to make it work with Lilley’s busy schedule—which includes raising five kids. They offered to condense 12 weeks’ worth of Theresa’s material into a four-week shooting block. Lilley agreed to the grueling pace.
“And then, after two weeks, they decided to use Emily instead, and I don’t know why they did that, but that’s what happened. It was like just a miscommunication,” Lilley revealed, adding, “I didn’t know I was being replaced… Oh, it was a major plot twist, and yeah, it was not handled well, and Emily didn’t know, but she knew before me. I mean, it was a little bit of a kerfuffle, that’s for sure.”
Despite the messy communication, Lilley insists there is zero bad blood on her end—and fans shouldn’t hold their breath for a Salem comeback anytime soon.
“No, because the reason Emily replaced me is because I said I couldn’t do the show. So it’s like, there really was no hard feelings. The way that situation was handled wasn’t the best way, but like, there’s really no beef,” she said. “I have five kids. Like, I’m not in the zone of my life to be able to do soap operas right now.”
Would She Return?
Looking back at her time in daytime, Lilley still appreciates the wild ride that comes with soap storytelling—even if she jokes she could never dream up those plotlines herself.
When asked about a return, Lilley said, “I can’t come up with the story lines that they have on soap operas, because it was always the wildest stuff.“
“It was like, ‘Oh, today I have a fetal kidnapping. That’s interesting. Can’t wait to play that,’” she said.
“People don’t understand on the outside, you know, that aren’t fans of soap operas—’cause I didn’t grow up being a fan of soap operas—I did not understand that the people are not actually overacting. It’s just that the stakes are so wildly high that if you don’t play it to the hilt, then the audience is going to be like, ‘You’re a liar.’”
Watch the full interview with Jen Lilley below! (Note: the Days piece is at the 47:47 mark of the video)
Would you like to see Jen return to Salem for a short visit someday? Tell us in the comments!
Photo Credit: JPI Studios.
Follow Soap Opera News on Google News to stay up to date with all the latest news, spoilers, recaps, interviews, and more.





Leave a Reply